ICU Delirium vs Sedation: RASS and CAM-ICU for EDAIC
Distinguish arousal, agitation and delirium through an original ICU assessment exercise, using RASS, CAM-ICU and the 2025 PADIS focused update.

Sedation assessment and delirium assessment answer different questions. RASS describes a patient's level of arousal and agitation. CAM-ICU assesses features of delirium in a patient who can be assessed. A quiet patient is not automatically free of delirium, and an agitated patient has not been diagnosed simply by appearing restless.
For EDAIC, the most useful skill is to explain what each observation supports, what it leaves uncertain and what needs reassessment. Drug names belong later in that reasoning.
Begin with arousal
The original RASS validation study evaluated a scale ranging from marked agitation to unresponsiveness. Its purpose is structured assessment of agitation and sedation, not a standalone identification of the cause of altered behaviour.
This distinction matters when reading a chart. A recorded arousal score is an observation at a particular time. It should not be expanded into “neurologically normal” or “delirium excluded” without the assessments needed to support those claims.
Also distinguish the intended sedation target from the observed state. “The plan is light sedation” describes an intention. The measurement tells you whether that intention was achieved at that time. An accurate viva answer keeps the two separate.
Try 10 EDAIC questions free
Create a free account and answer EDAIC-style Part 1 MTF questions — each one graded per statement, with a full explanation.
Then ask whether delirium can be assessed
CAM-ICU was developed and validated for critically ill patients, including those receiving mechanical ventilation. Intubation does not automatically make delirium assessment impossible. Profoundly reduced arousal, however, can prevent a meaningful assessment; an unassessable state should not be recorded as a negative test.
The core features involve acute change or fluctuation, attention, thinking and level of consciousness. Use the instrument's actual instructions rather than inventing a shorthand such as “confused equals positive”. A positive screen prompts assessment of the syndrome and its contributors; it does not identify one specific cause.
Original exercise: three short notes
Consider these hypothetical notes:
Note A: “Comfortable and quiet. No delirium.”
Note B: “Deeply unresponsive during current sedation. Delirium assessment not possible at present.”
Note C: “Arousal assessed; patient able to participate. A structured delirium assessment is positive, with new fluctuating inattention compared with baseline.”
Note A contains a conclusion that is not justified by the observation supplied. Quiet behaviour alone is insufficient. Note B separates an assessment limitation from a negative result. Note C provides a clearer chain from observed state to structured assessment and baseline comparison.
The exercise is not asking you to diagnose three patients from two sentences. It asks which documentation preserves uncertainty honestly. In both exams and chart interpretation, that is an important clinical reasoning skill.
Hypoactive does not mean harmless or absent
Agitation attracts attention because it is visible. A less active patient may generate fewer alarms or interruptions, but reduced activity is not proof of normal cognition. This is one reason structured screening is more useful than relying on whether a patient is disruptive.
For a revision exercise, remove the words “agitated” and “quiet” from a vignette. Ask what evidence remains about attention, change from baseline and fluctuation. If the answer is “almost none”, you have identified the missing assessment rather than reached a diagnosis.
The 2018 PADIS guideline places routine delirium assessment within a broader approach to pain, sedation, mobility and sleep. Those domains interact, but they should not be collapsed into one label.
Answer an EDAIC-style question
This is one exam-format Part 1 multiple-true-false question from our bank. Mark each statement true or false, then see the worked answer.
Regarding the pathophysiology of oxygen delivery and consumption in circulatory shock:
Mark each statement true or false:
In healthy adults at rest, systemic oxygen delivery is approximately 1000 mL/min while oxygen consumption is about 250 mL/min, creating a physiological oxygen reserve.
When systemic oxygen delivery decreases, oxygen consumption immediately falls in direct proportion, indicating supply dependency at all levels of DO₂.
Cardiac output is determined by the product of heart rate and stroke volume, with stroke volume being influenced by preload, afterload, and myocardial contractility.
The unifying feature of all forms of shock, regardless of aetiology, is acute circulatory failure associated with inadequate cellular oxygen utilisation.
In septic shock, early goal-directed therapy targeting supranormal oxygen delivery values has been shown to consistently reduce mortality across all patient populations.
Build a cause-focused discussion
Once a concerning change has been identified, an exam answer should assess potential contributors in the clinical context: physiological disturbance, illness, medication effects, pain and environmental or sensory factors, among others. Avoid the shortcut “positive screen, therefore give a sedative”. Sedation can change visible behaviour without resolving why it occurred.
Make a two-column list: observed problem and possible contributor to investigate. Keep the second column provisional until the vignette supplies evidence. If several contributors are plausible, say so. Multifactorial reasoning is often more defensible than choosing one memorable drug as the entire explanation.
Use the ICU viva preparation guide for answer order and context-sensitive half-time when discussing why a medication's effects may persist after its infusion changes.
What the 2025 PADIS update adds to revision
The 2025 focused update conditionally favours dexmedetomidine over propofol when light sedation and/or reduced delirium are the highest priorities in mechanically ventilated adults. It does not establish that one sedative suits every situation.
It also reports insufficient evidence to recommend for or against antipsychotics over usual care for delirium treatment. Do not paraphrase that as proof that they always work, never work, or are universally prohibited. The uncertainty is part of the recommendation and belongs in an evidence-aware answer.
This is a useful habit when reading any update: retain the patient group, the comparison and the strength of the recommendation. Removing those qualifications can turn a careful statement into an inaccurate universal rule.
Retrieval questions
Does RASS diagnose delirium? No. It describes arousal and agitation; delirium requires its own appropriate assessment.
Can intubated patients ever undergo delirium assessment? Yes. CAM-ICU was developed for this setting; communication limitations and assessability must be handled according to the tool.
Is “unable to assess” equivalent to “negative”? No. The first reports a limitation. The second reports an actual assessment result.
Does making a patient quieter prove delirium has resolved? No. Behaviour, arousal and cognition are related but distinct observations.
Use the AnesCORE question bank to practise identifying which of those observations a statement actually describes.
Sources
- Sessler et al: validation of the Richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale
- Ely et al: validation of CAM-ICU in mechanically ventilated patients
- SCCM 2025: focused update to PADIS guidelines
- SCCM 2018: PADIS guideline
Prepared with AI assistance for examination revision; sources checked 6 November 2026. These original teaching examples are not official EDAIC questions. Not a patient-care protocol.
Start preparing for EDAIC Part I
Syllabus-mapped lessons, 30,000 MTF questions, spaced-repetition flashcards and an AI study plan — in one platform.
Start free